The comment box below invites readers to comment.
Phil Beaver
seeks to collaborate on the ineluctable truth. Ineluctable means: Not to be assailed, avoided, broken, changed,
escaped, mystified, neglected, obfuscated, rationalized, resisted, revoked, or
voided. Some people erroneously imagine limiting the ineluctable truth, for
example, trying to change it.
"Civic"
refers to citizens who collaborate for individual
happiness with civic integrity more than for the city, state, nation, or
society. Civic citizens neither initiate nor accommodate harm to or from
anyone. Civic citizens are reliably responsible to the good rather than the bad
in connections and transactions.
Consider
writing a personal paraphrase of the preamble, which offers fellow citizens
mutual appreciation: For discussion, I convert the preamble’s predicate phrases to nouns and
paraphrase its proposal as follows: The civic faction, We the People of the United States,
proffer & practice 6 public pursuits —- integrity, justice, safety,
strength, prosperity, and responsibility, “in order to” pursue happiness “to
ourselves and our Posterity”. I want to improve
my interpretation by listening-to and considering other citizens and their
interpretations yet would preserve the original, 1787 text, unless it is
amended by the civic-people.
It seems the
Supreme Court occasionally refers to it, and no one with status has challenged
whether or not the preamble is a legal statement. The fact that it changed this
independent country from a confederation of states to a union of states
deliberately managed by appreciative fellow citizens convinces me the preamble
is legal. Equity in opportunity and outcome is shared by the faction who
collaborate for statutory justice, We the People of the United States.
Every citizen
has equal opportunity to either trust-in and collaborate-on the goals stated in
the preamble or be dissident to the agreement. I think 2/3 of citizens try
somewhat to use the preamble but many do not articulate commitment to the
goals. However, it seems less than 2/3 understand that “posterity” implies
grandchildren to both born Americans and legal immigrants. Congressional
freedom of religion, which fellow citizens have no means to constrain,
oppresses freedom to develop integrity. This can be remedied by changing the
First Amendment from “prohibiting” to “promoting”.
Selected theme from this month
Necessary goodness is often unknown, so may and can be
pursued. Its appeal to humankind can be accepted by civilizations, nations, states,
cities, churches, families, and citizens. However, good behavior is chosen by
the civic citizen – here, the faction We the People of the United States.
I write opinion, because I do not know the ineluctable truth.
But necessary goodness is accommodated by both Genesis 1, 5500 year old political
philosophy, and the United States Constitution, 234 years ratified.
Genesis 1:26-28, 31, asserts that it is good that humankind
has the responsibility to pursue order to life on earth.
In its amenability by the civic faction and its intentions “to
ourselves and our Posterity”, stated in the preamble, the United States pursues
statutory justice: written law containing no injustices.
Life to each family is challenging. The purpose of church is
to support the family in its quest to discover necessary goodness and consequently
practice good behavior to each family member. Pursuit of mystery is divisive to
the family and its members.
#USpreambler,
#acivicpeople
News
https://www.theepochtimes.com/opinion/we-must-renew-patriotic-education-5885600
I object to (customary) distractions from necessary
goodness.
To the civic faction, We the People of the United States,
patriotic education clarifies the necessary goodness that motivates and
inspires responsible behavior “to ourselves and our Posterity”. The civic
faction aids and appreciates the rule of law and its enforcement-branches unto
statutory justice, which the United States pursues through its Constitution.
History’s events if not reports make it clear that humankind
may and can pursue good behavior. Badness happened and need not obscure
necessary goodness. The war against England, successful in 1783, need not
overshadow the republic the 13 free and independent states intended in 1787 and
effected, together with the 14th state, by ratifying the amended United States
Constitution on December 15, 1791.
Patriots effect if not know that only civic individuals
collaborate for the associations that empower a nation to pursue necessary
goodness on earth. The civic faction aids reforming dependency, constraining
wickedness and crime, and annihilating evil.
Attention to divine liberty and freedom represses patriotic
aid to good behavior. Settlers in English colonies of North America, recognizing
that they were being enslaved as masters over African-slaves, declared war
against King George and Parliament. Englishman John Locke had written in 1690
that the civic citizen intends “to preserve himself, his liberty and property”.
Without royal authority to free African-slave properties, colonial Thomas
Jefferson wrote the Locke-mimic “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness”. Jefferson
resisted calling slaves “property”, when civic and civil independence from the
world’s mightiest empire was his purpose.
But Congress called slaves “property” until after the Civil
War, when the 13th and 14th amendments reversed the Dred
Scott decision. Necessary goodness is its own driver, and patriots aid the
pursuit.
#USprembler, #acivicpeople
Opinion
Lorenc
wrote that Marx’s communism starts with abolition of personal property then
jumped to soul -- a strawman fallacy. He
quoted Solzhenitsyn:
“We
have to condemn publicly the very idea that some people have the right to
repress others. In keeping silent about evil, in burying it so deep within us
that no sign of it appears on the surface, we are implanting it, and it will
rise up a thousandfold in the future.”
No
one justly imposes soul-concern on another.
Religious
institutions impose on innocent children doctrine about universal mystery, like
"soul", dividing humankind over what no civilization knows. The
consequence is religious adults imposing on children, victimizing them in war.
Aristotle,
d. 322 BC, said “Give me a child [through age] seven and I will show you the
[person].” It’s beyond surprising that, after 2350 years people still try to
enslave society to soul. After everything humankind has discovered, how can
churches try to persuade children to spend their opportunity to live, striving
for favorable afterdeath – that vast time after mind, body, and person stopped
functioning?
Each
person may and can pursue necessary goodness and consequential good-behavior
until their last breath. Both Genesis 1 and the United States Constitution
influence the civic faction to pursue necessary goodness “to ourselves and our
Posterity”, as confirmed by whatever constrains the consequences of personal
choices -- the god, the laws of physics, or unknown.
#USpreambler,
#acivicpeople
https://www.theepochtimes.com/opinion/the-human-element-in-warfare-5888982
Latham's title for the article, together with, "The
motivations that lead nations to engage in warfare . . . are deeply rooted in
human nature", seem to me to misrepresent or neglect humankind's
responsibility: to discover and practice necessary goodness.
Latham's "moral imperatives that guide our
actions" may and can be addressed by every education department on earth.
Necessary goodness is the guide, and good behavior is the practice. The
consequences of human choice offer the record of errors, not to be repeated by
anyone; hence the necessity of integrity in reporting and considering
happenings.
Necessary goodness requires civic citizens to reform
slackers, dissidents, and rebels; constrain criminals; avoid and resist
wickedness; and annihilate evil. Among civic citizens, good behavior is its own
reward.
#USpreamber, #acivicpeople
To Van Hamlin:
A couple of considerations:
First, the person who reportedly said that we should use his
name was Yeshua. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yeshua. Since discovering
this, I have read the Complete Jewish Bible for NT and the Orthodox Jewish
Bible for OT, to compare with NIV. Yeshua's influence has always guided my
life, as I discovered 3 years ago. Yeshua always urges necessary goodness.
Second, John may have been accurate when he opined that
Yeshua was present in the beginning. John 8:58, CJB, "Yeshua said to them,
“Yes, indeed! Before Avraham came into being, I AM!”
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John%208&version=CJB .
If so, Yeshua may be the judge represented in Genesis 1:31,
OJB; "And G-d saw every thing that He had made, and, behold, it was tov
me’od (very good)." Since G-d, in Genesis 1:26-28 gave humankind dominion
over life on earth, praying for G-d to take charge seems a request for
usurpation of assigned duty.
It seems that if there will be a peaceful world, civic
citizens will intend to make it happen.
#USpreambler, #acivicpeople
Quora
The civic faction, We the People of the United States,
accept that discovering and practicing necessary goodness is humankind’s purpose
“to ourselves and our Posterity”. Posterity includes legal immigrants.
Civic integrity prevails as good behavior — never repeat an
error, whether experienced or observed, for example, in church stories.
Necessary goodness is disclosed by the physical and psychological consequences
of human choices.
After 5500 years, empowered with language, writing, grammar,
and thought, churches may and can reform from establishing and maintaining
doctrine grounded in mystery. By not dividing people over mystery no one knows,
churches may and can facilitate attention to humankind rather than war for
civil favor among humankind. Thus, churches may and can protect their children
from the ravages of war.
I support a church, hoping to influence such reform after 45 years there. I
think reform is possible.
#USpreambler, #acivicpeople
Not only that, non-penetrating sodomy between soldiers is
encouraged by military rules. Institutional benefits nevertheless damage if not
ruin perpetrators’ psychologies.
My dad, whose dad died of cancer when Dad was 12, taught me
sex by secrecy regarding Mom submitting to a mysterious god.
One day, home alone and threatened, I searched for the hand gun I knew dad kept
and found some strange, homemade toys.
I managed to avoid psychological threats to my life, because as an adolescent I
realized that any abuse I subjected myself to would be known by the other party
and haunt me. I turned down Judy’s piece and Kay’s blow job.
And then I met my bride — a serenely confident school
teacher. During courtship, I perceived she felt she had found her mate. It was
up to me to protect us from passionate pregnancy.
I was aware of Yeshua’s influence, in Matthew 19:3–5: “Some P’rushim came and
tried to trap [Yeshua] by asking, “Is it permitted for a man to divorce his
wife on any ground whatever?” He replied, “Haven’t you read that at the
beginning the Creator made them male and female, and that he said, ‘For this
reason a man should leave his father and mother and be united with his wife,
and the two are to become one flesh’?”
An authentic man takes responsibility to prevent unwanted pregnancy. I think
every adolescent, female as well as male, should know this psychology and other
political philosophy with physical consequences that Yeshua expressed.
Every education department may and can reform so as to
inculcate comprehension and intention to human being (the practice).
I write opinion, because I do not know the ineluctable truth.
#USpreambler,#acivicpeople
https://www.quora.com/What-fixes-the-chasm-between-how-things-are-and-how-things-ought-to-be? Hadissah Magoncia
Most people think
their behavior ought to be good and want to behave. Therefore, they pursue
necessary goodness. However, individuals, societies, and nations often face
situations wherein they can neither judge necessity nor know that no action is
required.
But repeated bad consequences, when humans don’t choose good behavior, make it
plain that indolence, badness, and wickedness must be resisted and avoided. And
evil must be annihilated.
The evolution of civilization records the mistakes that necessary goodness
could have avoided. The Internet makes it possible to discover past human error
and avoid repetition.
Wikipedia may be used to explore mistakes
the reader suspects. My purpose is to avoid repetition of suspected human
error. For example, I appreciate, Yeshua, whose political philosophy to necessary
goodness some writers resist using “Jesus” or “Christ”.
So far, religions and governments impose higher powers:
mysteries and war, neglecting if not hiding humankind’s obligation to provide
order on earth and to human extensions.
To reform the chasm created by religions and government, the
civic faction of humankind, the individuals, societies, and nations who oppose
indolence, badness, wickedness, and evil may and can require every education
department to reform so as to facilitate, encourage, and promote the human
desire for good behavior.
Only with intention can a human individual resist or prevent
repeating human error.
#USpreambler, #acivicpeople
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/john.hu.14606
https://www.facebook.com/mick.kassem,
July 30
If boys understood that girls just want to have phunn to
relieve resilient responsibility, the world could improve to necessary
goodness.
Nations must stop subjecting children to war (Mrs. Trump), and religions must
stop indoctrinating children unto divisive doctrine about mystery.
https://www.facebook.com/taylor.pack.37,
Aug 16
Good morning, Taylor.
What a wonderful adventure you are living!
Your outcrop-photo reminds me of my youth in Knoxville, TN, living near rocks
(near the Tennessee River) I climbed, looking for fossils. When I started
college, I threw my collection away, knowing I could easily replace each item
-- fishbacks, snail, etc.
Yesterday, I met with a rabbi for 2 hours and learned that, to him, Yeshua is
not a feature of mainstream Jewish literature.
But the rabbi was fascinated by the concept of necessary goodness. To Jewish
mentors, Hillel the Elder(d. 10 CE), his grandson Gamaliel (d. maybe 50), and
Maimonides (d. 1204), I added Yeshua (d. 33), researching the dates after the
meeting.
The rabbi asked me to spell "Yeshua" then insisted on Jesus as
non-feature. However, "Yeshu" is a controversial feature;
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesus_in_the_Talmud.
I doubt we'll meet again, but I am forever changed by the discussion.
Regardless, Yeshua, who I think suggested necessary goodness (e.g., Matthew
5:48), remains my mentor to good behavior.
Please see my latest FB post to understand "mentor".
Please tell Meridith "hello".
https://www.facebook.com/phil.beaver.52,
Aug 20
Nations must stop subjecting and trafficking children in war
(Mrs. Trump), and religions must stop indoctrinating children unto divisive
doctrine about mystery to everyone.
Aug 16
I think the civic faction, We the People of the United States, accommodates
reform “to ourselves and our Posterity”. “Posterity” includes legal immigrants.
From the beginning of language and grammar, there have been
precocious thinkers who imagined necessary goodness. That is, observing the
consequences of human choices, thinkers, in their generation’s era of
discovery, imagined recording both mistakes to not repeat and goodness to
practice.
Scholars happily research the inventors of writing and grammar: primitive
Sumerian civilization and competitors, such as the Egyptians, Asians, and
others.
Discovers of necessary goodness are celebrated. The Code of
Ur-Nammu, 4100 old, celebrates kings who deliver justice, e.g., to care for
widows and orphans. Anaxagoras, 2500 years ago, reported that the moon is not a
god. Socrates asked if humankind appreciates goodness more than gods. Hillel,
2000 years ago said, “That which is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow,” without
the Internet, mimicking Confucius, 500 years earlier. Maimonides (died 1204)
said charity is: to aid a person’s quest for independence. Yeshua, executed in
33 CE, said, “Be perfect [like a god]” (Matthew 5:48 and Psalm 82). Ralph Waldo
Emerson (Divinity School Address, 1838) appreciated and promoted the message:
be perfect.
Alas, Yeshua is not celebrated as a political philosopher. By
making Yeshua divine, by waiting for an anointed one, and by seeking
retribution, Abrahamic believers, about 3.5 billion of 8 billion people on
earth, hold hostage necessary goodness. War seems preferred more than good
behavior.
The civic faction, so far, cannot reform badness, constrain criminality,
discourage wickedness, and annihilate evil. I think humankind is at the abyss
and may reform.
By 350 CE, Vetus Latina was complete and Iesus (pronounced
Yehsus) was announced as the fulfillment of the 200 BC Tanakh’s prophesied
Messiah. The 500 CE Talmud controversially mentions the Hebrew name “Yeshua”,
perhaps referring to the Aramaic “Isho”. But Yeshua is not a feature of modern
Judaism.
Through translations and transliteration, 0 CE's Yeshua became “Jesus” in 1557
(Geneva Bible). “Jesus”, a constructed divinity, is only 500 years old,
compared to Yeshua, a person who, 2000 years ago, observed and thought about
that which constrains the consequences of human choices but did not write.
I do not know the ineluctable truth. Discussion, yesterday, with Rabbi Peretz Kazen,
happily provided insights to this opinion.
#USpreambler, #acivicpeople
Aug 14
I hope readers take Yeshua seriously rather than dismiss him
as "Jesus", which replaced the Latin "Iesus" only 500 years
ago.
Yeshua did not write. Consequently, students can only pursue that real-person’s
ideas within the universes of opinions about writers' constructs.
Lately, I am focused on necessary goodness and the pursuit of good behavior,
discernable from civic citizens, past and present, including Yeshua the
Nazarene of 2000 years ago.
Most scripture strains to match or better the Jewish literature, which may
deflect preceding Sumerian physical and psychological achievements, such as
invention of writing, grammar, and law codes.
In later literature, whereas Moses struck a rock to produce water, Yeshua
turned water into wine. Whereas Elijah raised a person from the death bed,
Yeshua resurrected a corpse from 4 days’ death. Even though writers report
Yeshua doing miracles or claiming he is the Messiah, his personal conversations
and speeches encourage good behavior (e.g., Matthew 5). Often, he re-directs a
question to teach good choices (e.g., Matthew 19:3-5). When Pilate asked the
accused if he is a king, Yeshua answered, “Everyone who belongs to the truth
listens to me” (John 18:37).
I think the primary incentive to pursue Yeshua rather than another entity, such
as Jesus, Christ, or other, is to study Yeshua’s influence to necessary
goodness, in order to strengthen personal intentions and practice to good
behavior rather than bad.
As student of Genesis 1:26-28,31, Yeshua reportedly said, “Be perfect” (Matthew
5:48). This demand implies that the listener CAN be perfect, if he or she has
the intention. I prefer to intend perfection rather than accept that I am a
sinner to repeat mistakes.
Consider some celebrated constructs about Yeshua, the person, as follows.
James, Yeshua’s brother, wrote (James 1:1) to the 12 tribes in exile, or Jews,
that; observing the perfect Torah gives freedom (James 1:25), the executed
Yeshua’s return to unite the tribes was near (James 5:8), and that tribe
members should help each other avoid erroneous living (James 5:20). It seems
James wrote of salvation from erroneous living rather than for favorable
afterlife.
Peter, hoping to represent the named apostles, influenced that to perfect
Jewish obedience (Matthew 5:17-20) and blood sacrifice (Leviticus 17:11)
facilitates salvation also to Gentiles (John 1:1-29). Additionally, Yeshua’s
execution was sufficient blood sacrifice for every person who was chosen to
believe, past, present, and future (Hebrews 9:25-28).
Paul, a self-proclaimed representative for the Gentiles, wrote that obeying
male circumcision was unnecessary, and salvation through Yeshua’s execution was
a gift to the afterdeath rather than to obedient living – grace to souls rather
than to obedient persons (1 Thessalonians 4:16-17). Paul and Peter held in
common belief in salvation through Yeshua’s execution.
John, an apostle, wrote that Yeshua was in fact The God (John 1:1,29). The God
self-incarnated so as to sacrifice blood.
I did not find Jewish literature that claims Yeshua impacted Israel. The few
“Messianic Jews”, perhaps 200 thousand of 15 million Jews, are split between
Yeshua anointed for the Jews and Christians -- Jews who by grace believe Yeshua
died to redeem their souls; antinomians.
Arabs and some other humans seem to think Yeshua was a prophet.
As we struggle to reform life among humankind, I hope Yeshua’s influence to
necessary goodness aids repressing traditional badness and wickedness, through
individual and collaborative preferences to good behavior by individuals,
societies, and nations.
I write opinion, only because I do not know the ineluctable truth.
#uspreambler, #acivicpeople
https://www.facebook.com/emily.toth.10/posts/10235575281515942,
Aug 13
Some women are so genuinely good that one man courts her for
life. I was lucky enough to court Cynthia for 58 years.
I hope this is meaningful and impactful rather than competitive.
Aug 12
I think focus on necessary goodness may and can motivate and
inspire a person to pursue good behavior.
https://www.facebook.com/PattiGarner/posts/10162098280187896,
Aug 11
A woman is responsible for the eggs she generates and
exposes to insemination. She has responsibility to the
consequentially-conceived human being, whether she accepts it or not.
As spouse to a woman of intentional goodness, I think our 3
children demonstrate physical and psychological pursuit of necessary goodness
and personal quest to good behavior. Necessary goodness is often unknown.
Fortunately to me, I lived long enough to discover that I
choose necessary goodness rather than pursue the god. When my wife died at age
84, I wrote for her eulogy, "She chose necessary goodness and humbly
inspires those who don’t comprehend."
When I wooed her, I mistakenly felt that if I changed to her
religion I'd be giving up my humanity. My delusion impacted our children. I
cannot say they are better for it, but they improve humankind, to their credit.
It's been 2350 years since Aristotle thought, and our generation, perhaps the
123rd, benefits from history's discovery of what constrains the consequences of
human choice. The time for indoctrinating children into anything but good
behavior in humankind's quest for necessary goodness has long since past.
Thank you for sharing ideas that prompted this response.
Phil
Beaver does not “know.” He trusts in and is committed to theineluctabletruth, which
can only be discovered. Conventional wisdom has truth founded on reason, but it
obviously does not work.
Phil is agent
for A Civic People of the United States, a Louisiana, education non-profit
corporation. See online at promotethepreamble.blogspot.com, and consider essays
from the latest and going back as far as you like. He uses the hashtag
#USpreambler.